Open Adoption in Colorado: What's Enforceable and What Isn't
Open Adoption in Colorado: What's Enforceable and What Isn't
Open adoption is a spectrum — it can mean anything from a birth parent receiving annual photo updates to regular in-person visits throughout childhood. Colorado law took a major step forward in 2021 in formalizing and protecting these arrangements. But many families still enter open adoption agreements that have no legal standing because they weren't structured correctly.
Understanding the difference between what's enforceable and what's just a promise matters significantly for both birth parents and adoptive families.
What Open Adoption Means in Colorado
Colorado doesn't have a single legal definition of "open adoption." The term describes any adoption where there is ongoing contact or communication between the adoptive family and the birth family — whether that's letters, photos, emails, phone calls, or in-person visits.
For most of Colorado's adoption history, these arrangements were purely voluntary. Adoptive families could agree to send photos or allow visits, but birth parents had no legal mechanism to enforce the agreement if the adoptive family stopped following through. Similarly, adoptive families had no certainty that a birth parent would respect boundaries they'd agreed to.
Colorado's approach changed significantly with HB 21-1101.
HB 21-1101: The Post-Adoption Contact Agreement Law
Enacted in 2021 and codified at C.R.S. § 19-5-203.5 (the same statutory section as Marlo's Law, which addresses a separate topic), HB 21-1101 created the legal framework for enforceable Post-Adoption Contact Agreements (PACAs) in Colorado.
What the law does:
- Formally recognizes written post-adoption contact agreements as legally enforceable
- Allows birth parents, adoptive parents, and in some cases siblings or grandparents to be parties to these agreements
- Provides a court mechanism for modifying or enforcing agreements when disputes arise
- Gives children age 12 and older a voice in agreeing to or modifying contact arrangements
Who can be included: Contact agreements can include birth parents, adoptive parents, adult biological siblings, biological grandparents, and other biological relatives with whom the child has an established relationship. The court reviews the parties and the proposed contact to ensure it serves the child's best interests.
The critical requirement: To be legally enforceable under Colorado law, a post-adoption contact agreement must be filed with the court prior to finalization of the adoption. An agreement made after finalization or an agreement that exists only as a letter or promise from the adoptive family is not enforceable through the courts.
This distinction is where many families get burned. Agencies sometimes encourage birth parents with promises of ongoing contact, but if that promise isn't structured as a formal PACA filed with the court before finalization, it's unenforceable. If the adoptive family later stops sending photos or refuses visits, the birth parent has no legal recourse.
Enforceability: What "Legally Binding" Actually Means
When a properly filed PACA is in place, either party can petition the court to enforce the agreement if the other party isn't following through. The court reviews the petition and determines whether:
- The agreement is being violated
- Enforcement serves the child's best interests
- The child (if 12+) consents to the enforcement
Enforcement does not automatically mean contempt or punitive action — courts prefer voluntary compliance. But it does mean there's a legal mechanism to hold parties accountable, which informal agreements don't have.
Modification: Either party can petition the court to modify the agreement if circumstances have changed. The court evaluates modifications based on the child's best interests. If the child is 12 or older, they must consent to any modification.
The 12-year rule: This is a notable protection for older children. Once a child reaches 12, they have a legal voice in contact arrangements. An adoptive family cannot unilaterally cut off contact that the 12-year-old wants to maintain, and a birth parent cannot demand contact that the child doesn't want.
Free Download
Get the Colorado Adoption Quick-Start Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
What Makes Open Adoption Work in Practice
Legal enforceability is a floor, not a ceiling. The families who navigate open adoption well typically don't rely on legal mechanisms — they rely on clear communication, realistic expectations set before finalization, and a mutual understanding of what the contact arrangement is actually for: the child's wellbeing.
Common elements of workable open adoption arrangements:
- Clear, specific agreement terms (annual photos vs. monthly emails vs. quarterly visits — specificity matters)
- Defined point of contact and communication method
- Agreement on what happens if major life events change the picture (relocation, remarriage, new siblings)
- A shared understanding of how the child's needs — not the adults' — drive contact decisions
Adoptive families who approach open adoption as a gift to the child rather than an obligation to the birth parent tend to sustain these arrangements more naturally. Birth parents who maintain appropriate boundaries around their role (supportive, loving, not destabilizing) make open adoption easier for everyone.
For Foster-to-Adopt Families
In foster-to-adopt cases, contact with biological relatives is a separate and more complex issue. During the foster care phase, the child welfare system typically requires visitation with biological parents as part of the reunification effort. Once TPR is granted and adoption begins, those mandated visits end.
Post-adoption contact in foster cases is less common than in private adoption, but it does occur — particularly for kinship adoptions and cases where the adoptive family has developed a positive relationship with biological relatives during the foster care period. The same PACA framework applies if you want that contact to be enforceable.
Questions to Ask Before Finalizing
If you're considering an open adoption arrangement:
- Is the agreement we're discussing going to be filed with the court as a formal PACA before finalization, or is it informal?
- What specific contact does the agreement provide for — letters only? Photo updates? Phone calls? Visits?
- How will disputes about contact be handled if they arise?
- What happens if we move out of state?
- Does the child (if old enough) understand and want this level of contact?
The Colorado Adoption Process Guide covers post-adoption contact agreements in the context of the full adoption process — including how to structure an enforceable agreement, what to discuss with your attorney before finalization, and how Colorado's 2021 law changed the landscape for families who want long-term birth family relationships.
Get Your Free Colorado Adoption Quick-Start Checklist
Download the Colorado Adoption Quick-Start Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.