Delaware Adoption Agencies: How to Choose the Right One

Delaware has fewer than a dozen licensed adoption agencies operating within its borders. That sounds manageable — until you realize that each one occupies a very different niche, and applying to the wrong one costs you a $300-$500 application fee and three months of your time before anyone tells you they can't help.

Here is what the state's official list does not tell you: which agency is right for your specific situation.

Why Agency Choice Matters More in Delaware Than in Larger States

In most states, the sheer number of licensed agencies gives you room to recover from a wrong first choice. Delaware's small-state ecosystem does not offer that cushion. The Office of Child Care Licensing (OCCL) enforces the DELACARE Regulations for Child Placing Agencies, which means every agency on the list is legitimate — but legitimacy is not the same as fit.

The two main gaps families run into:

1. Pathway mismatch. An agency that specializes in domestic infant placement cannot help a kinship family. An agency with only DFS contracts cannot handle an international adoption.
2. Geographic friction. If you live in Sussex County and your assigned agency operates primarily out of Wilmington, every required in-home visit adds a three-hour round trip to an already exhausting process.

The Licensed Agency Landscape in Delaware

Children & Families First

Best for: Foster care adoption, especially older children, medical fragility, and transracial placements.

Children & Families First runs the African American Adoption Program and has deep experience with children who have experienced trauma. They have offices in both Wilmington and Dover, and they offer statewide Zoom orientations — a genuine advantage for families in Kent and Sussex Counties. They hold a DFS contract, which means they can guide you through the full foster-to-adopt pathway.

A Better Chance For Our Children (ABCFOC)

Best for: Special needs and older child adoption; post-adoption support services.

ABCFOC operates out of Wilmington and Milford, giving them better geographic reach into southern Delaware than most agencies. Their strength is in working with children who have complex needs, and they provide some of the most comprehensive post-adoption support available in the state, including support groups, crisis intervention, and trauma-specialized therapy.

Children's Choice

Best for: Christian-based families pursuing foster care or international adoption.

With offices in Newark and Dover, Children's Choice serves families who want faith-aligned support throughout the process. They handle both DFS-contract foster care and international placements, making them one of the few agencies in Delaware that can serve a family if circumstances change mid-journey.

Adoptions from the Heart

Best for: Domestic infant adoption with an open adoption framework.

If you are pursuing infant placement and want ongoing contact with the birth family, Adoptions from the Heart is the strongest local option. Their Wilmington office focuses almost exclusively on domestic infant adoption and provides significant birth parent counseling, which makes the placement process more stable. Be aware that their model assumes open adoption — if you want a closed adoption, this agency is probably not the right fit.

Open Arms Adoption

Best for: Domestic infant adoption, all races; extensive birth parent support.

Open Arms operates out of Wilmington with a focus on infants of all racial backgrounds and emphasizes birth parent counseling before and after placement. They are well-regarded for ethical practice in open adoption situations.

Bethany Christian Services

Best for: Domestic infant, foster care, and stepparent services.

Bethany has statewide reach and a broader service menu than most Delaware agencies. They can assist with domestic infant placement, DFS-contracted foster care, and stepparent adoption support. Their Newark presence makes them accessible to the University of Delaware corridor and northern New Castle County.

Madison Adoption Associates

Best for: International adoption (Hague-accredited).

If you are pursuing international adoption, Madison is the only Hague-accredited agency in Delaware. Their Claymont office serves primarily New Castle County. International adoption through Delaware also requires compliance with federal immigration law and, in many cases, a re-adoption or registration proceeding in Delaware Family Court after you return home.

Adoption STAR

Best for: Broad support across domestic infant pathways; robust training and advocacy resources.

Adoption STAR operates statewide and provides a comprehensive support structure that emphasizes education and advocacy alongside placement services. They are a strong fit for first-time adoptive parents who want structured guidance throughout the process.

If You Are Considering a Pennsylvania Agency

Many Wilmington-area families look north toward Philadelphia-area agencies because of the larger "baby pool" and the perception of more resources. This is a legitimate option, but it comes with a specific complication: the Interstate Compact on the Placement of Children (ICPC).

If a Pennsylvania agency places a child with a Delaware family, both states must approve the placement before the child can come home with you. This approval process typically takes two to four weeks, during which you must remain in Pennsylvania. The Pennsylvania agency may also have limited familiarity with Delaware Family Court filing requirements — you may end up needing a Delaware attorney to bridge the gap.

Larger is not always better. A well-connected Delaware agency that has finalized hundreds of cases in the Family Court at 500 North King Street will often move faster and with fewer errors than a regional agency learning Delaware rules for the first time.

How to Vet Any Agency Before You Apply

Before paying an application fee, ask these questions:

1. How many Delaware-specific adoptions did you finalize in the last 12 months?
2. Do you hold a current license from the Delaware Office of Child Care Licensing (OCCL)? Ask for the license number so you can verify it independently.
3. If we are matched with a child from another state, do you have experience handling Delaware ICPC intake?
4. What are your full fees — not just the application fee, but the total agency fee structure from home study through finalization?
5. Do you have staff in a location that can conduct in-home visits without requiring me to travel to Wilmington?

The OCCL maintains the current licensed agency list. Agencies that have been placed on "warning of probation" or "probation" are flagged — this information is publicly available and worth checking before you sign anything.

Making the Decision

Your adoption pathway should drive your agency choice, not the other way around. The fastest path to the wrong outcome is selecting an agency because they had the best website, then discovering three months in that they do not serve your region or your adoption type.

If you are starting the process and not yet certain which pathway makes the most sense for your family — foster-to-adopt, domestic infant, kinship, international — the Delaware Adoption Process Guide walks through the cost, timeline, and eligibility for each pathway side by side, so you can make that decision before you walk into your first agency orientation.

See more United States guides →