Arizona Board of Fingerprinting Good Cause Exception

You applied for a Level 1 Fingerprint Clearance Card because you want to become a foster parent in Arizona. The denial letter arrived. It lists an offense from your past — maybe a decade-old DUI, a misdemeanor from your twenties, a charge that was dismissed but still shows on your record. The letter says your application has been denied.

This is where most people stop. They assume a denial is final and that their foster care application is over. It usually is not.

Arizona has a formal appeal process called the Good Cause Exception, administered by the Board of Fingerprinting. It exists specifically to review denied clearance card applications and grant exceptions for individuals who can demonstrate rehabilitation. Not every denial is appealable — some offenses are absolute bars with no exception. But many are not, and the Good Cause Exception process is the path forward.

Why Cards Get Denied

The Arizona Department of Public Safety (DPS) runs your fingerprints against state and federal criminal databases when you apply for a Level 1 Fingerprint Clearance Card. If the search returns a match to a precluding offense listed in Arizona statute, DPS issues an automatic denial.

The denial letter specifies the offense or offenses that triggered the denial. Read it carefully. The letter distinguishes between offenses that are absolute bars (no appeal possible) and offenses that are eligible for a Good Cause Exception.

There are also cases where a denial is triggered by an error — a name match to someone else's record, an arrest that did not result in a conviction, or a record that should have been sealed or expunged. If your denial is based on incorrect information, the first step is disputing the record with DPS and the relevant court, not filing a Good Cause Exception.

Absolute Bars Under ARS 8-804

Arizona law designates certain offenses as permanent, non-waivable disqualifiers for anyone seeking to work with or care for children. These are defined in ARS 8-804 and include:

• Sexual offenses involving a minor
• Murder and manslaughter
• Sexual assault
• Child abuse (felony level)
• Sexual exploitation of a minor
• Commercial sexual exploitation of a minor
• Kidnapping of a minor
• Certain domestic violence felonies involving serious physical injury

If your denial is based on an offense in this category, the Board of Fingerprinting cannot grant a Good Cause Exception. The bar is statutory and absolute — no amount of rehabilitation documentation, elapsed time, or personal testimony can override it. The denial letter from DPS will indicate whether the offense falls in this category.

This is not a judgment on your character. It is a legislative bright line. The legislature decided that certain offenses permanently disqualify a person from positions of trust involving children, and the Board has no authority to override that decision.

Offenses Eligible for Good Cause Exception

Everything that is not an absolute bar is potentially eligible for a Good Cause Exception. This includes a wide range of offenses:

• DUI and alcohol-related offenses
• Drug possession (non-trafficking)
• Theft, fraud, and property crimes
• Assault (non-aggravated, non-domestic violence involving serious injury)
• Disorderly conduct
• Criminal damage
• Certain misdemeanor domestic violence convictions
• Charges that resulted in plea agreements to lesser offenses

The age of the offense matters. The nature of the offense matters. Your conduct since the offense matters. But the key point is that a denial based on any of these offenses is not necessarily permanent. The Good Cause Exception exists precisely for people whose history includes mistakes that do not define their present character.

The Good Cause Exception Process

Step 1: Obtain and Review Your Denial Letter

The DPS denial letter is your starting document. It identifies the specific offense(s), the statute under which the denial was issued, and whether the offense is an absolute bar or eligible for appeal. If the letter indicates the offense is eligible for a Good Cause Exception, proceed to the Board of Fingerprinting.

Step 2: File a Good Cause Exception Application

The Arizona Board of Fingerprinting provides application forms on its website. The application requires:

• Your personal information and DPS application reference number
• A detailed description of the offense(s) — what happened, when, and the outcome
• A personal statement explaining your rehabilitation and why you should be granted an exception
• Supporting documentation (see below)
• An application fee

Be thorough and honest in the application. The Board reviews dozens of these petitions. Incomplete applications or applications that minimize or omit relevant facts work against you. Disclose everything — the Board will have access to your full criminal history regardless of what you include.

Step 3: Assemble Rehabilitation Documentation

This is the most important part of the application. The Board is evaluating whether you have demonstrated sufficient rehabilitation to justify an exception to the statutory disqualification. Strong documentation includes:

• Completion certificates for any court-ordered programs — substance abuse treatment, anger management, domestic violence intervention, community service
• Letters of support from people who know you personally and can speak to your character and conduct since the offense — employers, community leaders, clergy, therapists, sponsors
• Employment history showing stable, sustained employment since the offense
• Education or training completed since the offense
• Volunteer work or community involvement
• Therapy or counseling records (summaries, not full clinical notes) demonstrating ongoing self-improvement
• Court documents showing completed probation, satisfied restitution, or dismissal of charges
• Time elapsed since the offense — the more time that has passed without additional incidents, the stronger your case

The Board is looking for a pattern of sustained, documented change — not a one-time gesture. Five years of stable employment, completed treatment, and active community involvement tells a different story than a single letter from a friend.

Step 4: The Hearing

After your application is reviewed, the Board schedules a hearing. This is a formal proceeding where you present your case before Board members. You may attend in person or, in some cases, via video conference.

At the hearing:

• You present your personal statement and walk through your rehabilitation evidence
• Board members ask questions about the offense, your conduct since, and your reasons for seeking clearance
• You may bring witnesses who can speak to your character (though this is not required)
• If you have an attorney, they can represent you at the hearing

The hearing is not adversarial in the way a criminal trial is. The Board members are evaluating your rehabilitation, not re-litigating the offense. Be direct, take responsibility for what happened, and focus on demonstrating what has changed.

You do not need an attorney for the hearing, but legal representation can be helpful if the offense is complex, if there were multiple offenses, or if you are uncomfortable presenting your case alone. Some legal aid organizations in Arizona provide assistance with Good Cause Exception hearings.

Step 5: The Decision

The Board issues a written decision after the hearing. Outcomes include:

• Good Cause Exception granted: Your fingerprint clearance card is issued. You can proceed with your foster care licensing application.
• Good Cause Exception denied: The Board determines that insufficient rehabilitation has been demonstrated. You may be able to reapply after a waiting period, typically one to three years, depending on the Board's guidance.
• Request for additional information: In some cases, the Board may defer a decision and request additional documentation before making a final ruling.

If granted, the exception is specific to the purpose stated in your application (foster care licensing). It does not erase the underlying offense from your record.

Timeline

The Good Cause Exception process is not fast. From the date you file your application to the hearing date, expect 2 to 4 months, sometimes longer depending on the Board's caseload. The Board meets regularly but has a backlog. Factor this timeline into your overall foster care licensing plan.

If you know you have a criminal history that may trigger a denial, consider starting the fingerprint application as early as possible — even before your foster care orientation. The sooner a denial is issued, the sooner you can file the Good Cause Exception, and the less time the appeal process adds to your licensing timeline.

The Mistake People Make

The most damaging mistake is not the criminal history itself — it is hiding it. DPS and DCS conduct comprehensive background checks that surface arrests without convictions, dismissed charges, and records from other states. If you know about something in your past, disclose it proactively to your licensing specialist.

Licensing agencies work with imperfect histories regularly. A 10-year-old DUI with completed treatment and no subsequent incidents is something the system can accommodate. Discovering during a background check that an applicant concealed known history — even something that would not have been disqualifying — raises questions about honesty and trustworthiness under AAC R21-6-301. The concealment itself becomes the disqualifier.

If you have a history, tell your agency early. Ask whether the offenses are likely to trigger a denial. If they are, start the fingerprint application immediately so the denial and appeal process can run in parallel with the rest of your licensing steps.

The Arizona Foster Care Licensing Guide includes a Good Cause Exception preparation checklist, the complete list of absolute bar offenses under ARS 8-804, and a step-by-step timeline for managing the appeal process alongside your foster care licensing application.

See more United States guides →