Foster Care Background Checks in New York: SCR, DCJS, and Criminal History

The background check stage of New York's foster care process is where applicants go silent. A past arrest. A decade-old drug conviction. A relative living in the home with a criminal record. Most people don't ask about any of this at orientation because they're afraid the question alone will trigger a denial.

Here is what the law actually says about who can and cannot become a foster parent in New York — and what happens when your history is complicated.

The Legal Framework

Background checks for prospective foster parents in New York are governed by Social Services Law § 378-a and the federal Adoption and Safe Families Act (ASFA). These laws apply to every person aged 18 or older who resides in the home, not just the primary applicant. If your adult child, a partner, or a live-in relative is part of the household, they are subject to the same checks.

The process runs multiple parallel searches simultaneously:

1. DCJS Fingerprinting (New York State) Fingerprinting is conducted through IdentoGO, an authorized fingerprint provider with locations across New York. The fingerprints are run against the New York Division of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) database, which contains state criminal records.

2. FBI National Check The same fingerprint submission is also run through the FBI's national database, covering criminal records from all 50 states. This means a conviction in another state that you haven't disclosed will appear.

3. Statewide Central Register (SCR) The SCR is New York's database of child abuse and maltreatment reports. The agency submits form LDSS-3370 to check whether any household member has a prior substantiated report of child abuse or neglect in New York.

4. Sex Offender Registry The agency checks the New York Sex Offender Registry for all household members.

5. Justice Center Staff Exclusion List The Justice Center for the Protection of People with Special Needs maintains a list of individuals with substantiated findings of serious abuse or neglect in residential care settings. Any match is a disqualifier.

6. Interstate Registry Checks If any household member has lived in another state within the past five years, New York is federally mandated to request a child abuse registry check from that state. This is the most common source of delays — some states take weeks or months to respond to these requests. Notify your agency of any out-of-state addresses early in the process.

Mandatory Disqualifying Crimes

SSL § 378-a identifies specific crimes that result in automatic denial with no possibility of waiver. If any household member has a conviction for any of the following, the application must be denied:

Felony convictions at any time (no lookback period):

• Child abuse or neglect
• Spousal or domestic abuse
• Any crime against a child, including child pornography
• Crimes involving violence: rape, sexual assault, homicide (excluding physical assault or battery, which fall in the five-year lookback category)

Felony convictions within the past five years:

• Physical assault or battery
• Drug-related offenses

These are not subject to a safety assessment or case-by-case review. They are automatic denials.

What Happens With Other Criminal Records

For convictions not on the mandatory disqualification list, the agency conducts a safety assessment. This is not a rubber stamp — it is a genuine evaluation that considers:

• The nature and severity of the crime
• How long ago the conviction occurred
• Whether the sentence has been served and whether conditions (probation, parole) are still in effect
• Whether the offense involved children or vulnerable individuals
• Whether the person's circumstances have changed since the conviction

The important phrase in the regulation is "poses a risk to children in the home." Old, non-violent misdemeanors rarely fail this test, particularly when they're more than five to seven years in the past and the applicant is forthcoming about them.

The biggest mistake applicants make is omitting records they think won't show up. DCJS and FBI fingerprint databases are comprehensive. Arrests that didn't lead to convictions, dismissed charges, and sealed records may still appear on background check results, depending on the circumstances. Disclose everything proactively. An agency that discovers an undisclosed record will question your credibility across the entire application — not just the specific charge.

Arrests Without Convictions

An arrest that did not result in a conviction is generally not a disqualifying event. However, it will appear on background check results and will require explanation. Agencies are not permitted to deny an application solely on the basis of an arrest without conviction, but the circumstances surrounding the arrest will be reviewed as part of the safety assessment.

Records Involving the SCR

If the SCR search returns a substantiated finding of child abuse or neglect for any household member, the agency will conduct a review. Not all SCR records result in denial — the nature and date of the finding, and whether it was subsequently sealed, are relevant. However, a substantiated finding of serious abuse or neglect is treated similarly to a criminal disqualifier in practice.

When a Household Member Has a Record

The background check requirement extends to every adult in the home. If a partner, parent, or adult child who lives with you has a disqualifying conviction, their presence in the home is a barrier to certification — even if they are not applying as a foster parent. The agency's concern is with the safety of any child placed in the household, not just with the character of the primary applicant.

This situation can sometimes be addressed through living arrangement changes, but discuss this with your agency before assuming there is a straightforward workaround.

Understanding the Timeline

The SCR check is usually processed within a few days. DCJS results typically return in one to two weeks. The FBI national check takes two to four weeks. Interstate registry checks are the wild card — state response times vary from a few days to several months.

For applicants who have lived in multiple states, this is the most common source of timeline delays. The New York Foster Care Licensing Guide explains the full background check process in detail, including how to track the status of interstate checks and what to do if a state fails to respond within a reasonable timeframe.

A complicated history does not automatically mean a denied application. What it means is that you need to understand the rules, disclose accurately, and engage the process with documentation rather than anxiety.

See more United States guides →