Pennsylvania Adoption Agencies: How to Choose the Right One

Most Pennsylvania families spend weeks choosing an adoption agency before they understand what an agency actually does—and doesn't do—for them. The wrong choice can cost $30,000 and two years of your life. Here is what you need to know before you sign anything.

What Kind of Agency Do You Actually Need?

Pennsylvania has two fundamentally different types of adoption agencies, and mixing them up is the most common mistake first-time adoptive families make.

Private child-placing agencies (CPAs) are licensed by the PA Office of Children, Youth and Families (OCYF) and facilitate domestic infant adoption and international adoption. They conduct home studies, match birth parents with adoptive families, and provide required counseling. Their fees typically run from $25,000 to $45,000.

SWAN affiliate agencies are part of the Statewide Adoption and Permanency Network, the public-private partnership that handles foster care adoption. They are also licensed CPAs, but their services are largely state-funded when you are adopting a child already in Pennsylvania's foster care system. Most families adopting through SWAN spend less than $1,000 total.

If you want to adopt an infant privately, you need a private CPA. If you want to adopt a waiting child from the foster care system, you work through SWAN. These are separate processes with different timelines, costs, and risks.

The Major Private CPAs in Pennsylvania

Pennsylvania has dozens of licensed CPAs, but a handful handle the majority of domestic infant placements.

Adoptions From The Heart (AFTH) operates offices in Wynnewood (near Philadelphia) and Allentown, focusing on open domestic infant adoption. They are known for a robust birth parent outreach program and a relatively transparent fee structure.

Bethany Christian Services has branches in Central Pennsylvania (Harrisburg/Lancaster), the Greater Delaware Valley (Philadelphia suburbs), and Western Pennsylvania (Pittsburgh/Wexford). Faith-based but accepts families of all backgrounds.

Catholic Social Services of Philadelphia serves the five-county Philadelphia region with domestic infant and foster-to-adopt programs. Income-based fee scales are available.

The Children's Home of Pittsburgh provides domestic infant adoption and operates a transitional infant care facility—useful for families adopting medically complex newborns.

Jewish Family and Children's Service of Greater Philadelphia offers domestic, international adoption counseling, and post-adoption support across the Philadelphia metro area.

For a complete list of licensed agencies, the OCYF maintains a public registry. The Heart Gallery of America also publishes a Pennsylvania-specific directory of licensed domestic CPAs.

Questions to Ask Before You Commit to an Agency

Every agency will tell you they are responsive, ethical, and committed to your success. Ask these questions to separate the real answers from the marketing:

What is your average wait time from home study approval to placement? Legitimate agencies can give you a range based on their last 12–24 months of placements. Vague answers like "it depends" without data are a warning sign.

What is your full fee schedule, including variable costs? The quoted program fee is rarely the full cost. Ask specifically about home study update fees (common if your study expires before a match), birth parent counseling fees billed separately, and county-specific Orphans' Court filing fees.

How many placements disrupted in the past year, and why? Disruptions happen in even the best agencies. An agency that claims zero is either small or not being honest. One that can explain what happened and what changed is showing you institutional maturity.

Do you work with LGBTQ+ families, single parents, and families with existing children? Get this answer in writing. Some agencies have faith-based policies that restrict placements with certain family structures.

What do you do if a birth mother selects our family and then revokes consent within the 30-day window? Pennsylvania law gives birth mothers 30 days to revoke consent after signing. Understand the agency's process—and whether you get any fees returned—before you are emotionally invested in a match.

SWAN Agencies: A Different Process

If foster care adoption is your path, you do not choose an agency the same way you would for private adoption. The SWAN prime contractor (currently Diakon Lutheran Social Ministries in partnership with Voce) manages a network of over 140 affiliate agencies across all 67 Pennsylvania counties.

Your county Children and Youth Agency (CYA) will typically refer you to a SWAN affiliate in your area. You do not shop around for a SWAN affiliate the way you shop for a private CPA. The relevant questions are about your county CYA's responsiveness, wait times in your county for family profile approval, and which affiliate agencies have capacity to take new families.

The PA Adoption Exchange (PAE) hosts a photolisting of waiting children, and SWAN periodically holds matching receptions where families can meet caseworkers representing specific children.

What Agencies Cannot Do for You

An agency manages its own process. It does not manage the Orphans' Court, negotiate your adoption subsidy, or give you a complete view of all the pathways available in Pennsylvania. Many families discover after paying an application fee that the agency pathway they chose is either incompatible with their budget or slower than an alternative they never considered.

Understanding all four pathways—public foster care, private agency, independent, and kinship—before you pay a single application fee is how you protect yourself.

The Pennsylvania Adoption Process Guide walks you through each pathway with a decision framework, detailed cost breakdowns by pathway, and a checklist of questions to ask before you commit to any agency or attorney.

Making the Right Choice

There is no universally "best" adoption agency in Pennsylvania. The right agency is the one whose program, fees, timeline, and values align with your specific situation.

A private CPA placing infants is the wrong choice if you cannot sustain a $30,000–$45,000 cost. SWAN is the wrong choice if a very young infant is your only acceptable match. An independent adoption through an attorney may be faster and cheaper than agency adoption if you already have a connection to a birth family.

The first step is not choosing an agency—it is understanding which pathway fits your family, then choosing the right professional within that pathway.

Get a complete breakdown of all four Pennsylvania adoption pathways, along with what each actually costs and how long each takes, in the Pennsylvania Adoption Process Guide.

See more United States guides →